Thursday, October 9, 2014

Differing Views


Go anywhere in our country. Talk to people, or maybe just listen at a breakfast booth near another few people talking about the day over morning coffee. Listen to what they are chatting about. After comments of the day’s weather, they most likely will talk about what is in the news. Usually some sports on or just after the weekend, but then politics will rear its head.

In most social contexts we are polite and respectful of differences. We are trying to be pleasant, maybe even nice! But let one person offer an opinion on a political topic and watch out! If tempers visibly rise two things will happen: either the other people will remain silent, change the subject, or leave the immediate vicinity; or someone will begin the process of building a bridge to another point of view on the same topic.

I hope the latter springs up more and more. Building bridges helps others understand the complexity of the issue and why it is not easily solved. Differences of opinion should not automatically find the dummy in the crowd! Rather, discussion should unearth why the topic needs to be solved for the common good. Not solving the issue creates worse problems until solved, and in the meanwhile festering disagreements poison the peace and tranquility of the many moments.

Finding common ground is not easy but the process itself helps build trust and camaraderie needed for civil society to co-exist while finding meaningful solutions. We need a lot more of this behavior to build a stable future for our nation but also for others in the global community.

I read a news article this morning reporting that Democrat leaders in America are sidelining the President from many campaigns this election season because his approval ratings indicate he is a liability for many local campaigns of fellow Democrats. I think this is unfortunate. The President is one of the calm voices in political discourse today. His is a voice of history, past and present, and the building blocks of our tomorrows.

Political disagreement should not be based on personalities. They should be based on facts and broad hopes for the future. Focusing attention on those elements should serve us well in understanding issues and solving shared problems. Ideologies alone will rarely serve the discussion productively.  The outcome of our work together is the important thing. Results. Commonly used and needed. Our differences followed to the nth degree will lead us nowhere. Blockades of progress. Fights. Disruption. Incivility and ugliness.

Another article I read reported on ISIS attacks on the Kurdish/Turkey border and how the American led airstrikes may turn the tide and save the Kurdish towns. A citizen comment offered by an American reader of the article stated that the military should be left free to handle this skirmish to a successful conclusion while politicians should be removed from their self-serving decisions. I wonder if this person understands that American military decision making starts with civilian authority in order to avoid a military state. That is the constitutional reason for making the President the Commander in Chief. International relations and long range futures rely on building alliances not hegemony. Military solutions may be more pleasing over their certainty, but rarely do they build long lasting peace.

Life is not black or white, on or off, in or out. It is a constantly changing mix of elements. The right and wrong are relative and morphing into different relationships constantly. Understanding such basics is very difficult and nuanced. It takes patience, goodwill and deep caring for all the participants. Military solutions are none of these.

Often, as in the past, Senator Bernie Sanders (I-Vt) has something to say about this:

“Obama is being criticized for not being ‘aggressive’ and ‘forceful’ like Bush and Cheney. Thank God! Let’s not forget that Bush and Cheney got us into Iraq – the worse foreign policy blunder in modern American history.”

The President needs to be a peacemaker. With strong military backing peace will have a chance, but the talking and negotiating and understanding must be done with patience and openness. A gun held to the head may be persuasive in the short term but rarely in the long term.

Words to ponder for each of us.

October 9, 2014



No comments:

Post a Comment