Friday, March 11, 2016

Policing Chaos


Chicago’s headline yesterday morning was: ‘21 shot in 20 hours in Chicago.’ And this activity took place in a large, general region of the city where gangs are prevalent. Families of those gang members shrink in the homes out of fear of the violence their offspring or siblings will bring home with them. Shots are heard frequently in the neighborhood. Sirens are a constant chorus day and night. Of course they call the police in two circumstances: when the bullets are flying, or when they find family members dead from gun shot wounds.

The press is called if the police arrive and need to shoot their way to safety in this chaos. Somehow the police get tainted by their even being nearby in response to the calls for help. Then the spin gets applied: this is a cop shoot out.

I don’t know which came first, the chicken or the egg, in this matter. What I do know is residents living in fear in neighborhoods affected by gangs have a problem. And if they make the police the scapegoat they have an even greater problem. The police one day may not show up because they have allowed a chaotic environment to happen and propagate. Gangs do not appear overnight. They grow out of a destructive brew of social dysfunction focused on neighborhood, family and schools. Anti social behavior becomes a defensive act of survival. Churches often get involved to lessen the tensions but they are left powerless in the face of stubborn violence, deadly violence.

Churches, however, often become critics of police tactics. This turn of affairs allows families to blame police as well. When this happens they all lose. So do we in larger society.

Seems to me there are many resources to study and understand the problems inherent in the above scenario. What is lacking is a coming together of police, church, family and others who can lessen tensions and begin the delicate process of building peace. Currently we are stuck in indecision and lack of cooperation. Nothing much gets done that is good. Just tossing blame hither and yon. That simply does not work.

The police are caught in the middle of this chaos. They did not cause gangs to form. They are, however, charged with the responsibility of controlling gangs and lessening their impact on society. If the rest of society supported their efforts and helped them, police might actually gain some traction in their endeavors. Lacking that cooperation, police are dealing with a stalemate.

The result: 21 people get shot in 20 hours in the neighborhoods.

That problem belongs to all of us. Social unrest and violence is caused by heavy concentrations of population in tight quarters. Competition among residents for breathing room and education and opportunity pits too many people against one another. This is a social problem and a social disease. It comes from urban areas growing quickly. It comes from urban economies growing unequally and affecting poor people who become trapped living in areas that increasingly are unfit for habitation.

These problems are not new. They have been present throughout our history as a nation, and they are present in other nations as well that have disproportionate economic development and disproportionate economic rewards among the people of the region. The poor get poorer; the rich get richer. The latter move to safer areas which leaves the poor to manage a region in decline. And then more decline until conditions are not survivable and people die.

Help community leaders lead. Help police patrol the streets and keep them safe. Help the schools teach students about opportunity to fuel better lives. Help churches harbor the innocent and weak in times of crisis. But overall: participate in your community and help it be whole.

The police are not the enemy. They are but men and women like you being paid too little to risk their lives and health to protect yours when you are doing too little to help your own situation. Now is the time for you and your neighbors to stand united and work with others to end the chaos and violence. Only you can do it.

The alternative is growing violence until someone is declared the victor over the dead bodies. Is that what you really want?

And by the way, Chicago is not the only community with this problem. LA, New York, Pittsburgh, Miami, Philadelphia, Houston, Dallas and many other large urban areas have the same problems. None are immune. But all can do more to control the situation.

When will they. And we?


March 11, 2016

No comments:

Post a Comment